Our Top Reviewed Rums to Date
5 Stars
"What’s your favorite lemon dessert? It’s in here" (9/19/26)
"This is exactly what I want from a Caroni: industrial heft with a prominent layer of fruit and sweetness" (10/2/26)
"Grilled pineapple and stone fruit all over the place" (9/18/26)
"It’s winter spices, cherry cola, a bag of liquorice allsorts" (10/5/26)
"One of the absolute best aromas I can remember on a rum" (9/17/26)
"The bold flavors of Hampden swinging in a hammock of butterscotch" (9/12/26)
"You’re not going to stop tasting this one any time soon" (9/15/26)
4 Stars
"The light taste of watermelon flesh lingers behind on the tongue" (9/5/26)
"It’s an enticing mix of varnish and fruit desserts, with some earthy notes that call to mind the tropics" (9/24/26)
"Highly characteristic of the Hampden style with bursts of pineapple, citrus, and some of the industrial notes you get at the higher ester levels" (9/13/26)
"It delivers on what it promises in terms of a sophisticated, long-aged Jamaican rum" (9/23/26)
"Loads of sweet pineapple candy and stone fruit" (9/20/26)
"A lot of rich flavors that meld together into a decadent treat" (9/21/26)
"It’s got twists and turns that will delight a seasoned rum drinker" (10/3/26)
"You get a variety of fruity desserts" (10/1/26)
"This rum puts the palate through an absolute workout" (9/30/26)
"Once you sip it, it’s an explosion of sweet fruit" (10/4/26)
"This is a nice, tamed Port Mourant that’s a real crowd-pleaser" (9/27/26)
"It tastes like a rum you’re drinking in a tropical garden with fruit trees and flowering plants all around you" (9/26/26)
4 Stars
"You’d do well to grab yourself this 4 Años while you still can" (9/19/26)
"For $100, this is comparable to other funky Jamaican rums like Hampden HLCF Classic, and being at 69% makes it a pretty good deal" (9
/
$24
/
$26)
"For $100, this is comparable to other funky Jamaican rums like Hampden HLCF Classic, and being at 69% makes it a pretty good deal" (9
/
$24
/
$26)
"Even at $300 I think this is a good value pickup for what it’s delivering" (9
/
$20
/
$26)
"Even at $300 I think this is a good value pickup for what it’s delivering" (9
/
$20
/
$26)
"If you like Hampden at all, I’d buy it if you happen to see it anywhere online or in real life" (9/18/26)
"If you live in the States and you don’t own any Caroni yet, you should make this the one" (10/5/26)
"If you’re a Hampden lunatic like we are, you should see to it that you try this rum" (9/17/26)
"At $59 for a half bottle, it’s priced right if you want to experiment with the Spinnaker lineup" (9
/
$27
/
$26)
"At $59 for a half bottle, it’s priced right if you want to experiment with the Spinnaker lineup" (9
/
$27
/
$26)
"If you’re only going to get one bottle from the Spinnaker set, this is the one I’d recommend" (9/26/26)
"You might consider having it shipped to you from abroad" (9/12/26)
"It’s definitely worth including in an order" (9/15/26)