Reviewer: Tashtego
Distillery: Caroni
Origin: Caroni Plains, northwest Trinidad
Bottle Size: 700 ml
Bottle Count: Unstated
ABV: 51.4%
Distilled: 2000
Base Material: Molasses
Still: Column still
Aging specs: Aged 18 years in Trinidad
Bottled: 2018
Nose: Rubber, cherry, black licorice, baking spices
Palate: Rubber, chocolate cherry, diesel, crème brûlée, tea
Finish: Menthol, caramel
No place elicits more oohs and aahs from the rum world than the shuttered Caroni distillery in Trinidad. Famous for its complex industrial flavor, it’s the juice every rum nerd wants - the problem is finding it. In the US, your options are pretty much the Raising Glasses Perennia or buying a bottle at auction. Auction bottles tend to go for $300 at a minimum and can skyrocket from there. So is it worth it?
I won this particular bottle at Unicorn Auctions - it’s a Japanese import produced by La Maison & Velier (who own a significant percentage of the surviving casks of Caroni), and the retro 1940’s label celebrates the 100th anniversary of the distillery. It comes in at 90° imperial proof, or 51.4% ABV (don’t be confused by the big number on the label) and it’s been aged 18 years tropically in Trinidad. I love the box and label on this. It’s a beautiful bottle, and the sailors chilling and smoking a pipe on the docks are very charming.
On the nose, this exudes the characteristic rubber that people expect from a Caroni. After it sits for a bit, I get cherry and then a big hit of black licorice. I actually like the rubber note; it reminds me of brand new rubber balls you’d find in a big box in a hardware store as a kid. It’s the smell of summer fun. On the palate there’s more rubber, but then it evolves into a lot more. Cherry chocolate, crème brûlée, tea, and some industrial notes that make this a fun challenge for the taste buds. There’s some wood that’s been well-integrated into the overall flavor profile. I get something new on every sip. On the finish, there’s some menthol but also some classic rummy caramel/burnt sugar. It’s amazing all this can come from a column still rum, because it reminds me of the complexity of a pot still.
I come at this bottle as a Caroni novice. I’ve only sampled a handful in my life, so I can’t speak to where this bottle stacks up against the pantheon of Velier Caronis. That said, I find this to be a fun rum. The tire rubber isn’t a distraction for me, and there’s enough other stuff going on here that it’s enjoyable on many levels. For Taste, I’m going 5. Maybe not quite as strong a 5 as the Perennia, but it’s in the same conversation. For Haste, it’s a 3 because this is an auction-only buy and it cost me about $370, which makes it the second most expensive bottle I’ve ever bought. There seems to be a steady stream of these bottles going up at auction, so if you’re in the Caroni market and thinking of pulling the trigger on this, I don’t think you’d be disappointed.
Taste/Haste Scale: 5 / 3